The SOLO HS project is the first item on the agenda for the Public Hearing portion of the Saugerties Town Planning Board Meeting of Tuesday November 17th – The meeting will take place at 7:30 at the Saugerties Senior Center – NOTE: The room will likely be very very crowded, as the second item on the Public Hearing agenda is the KCE Battery proposal
First, apologies for the lack of follow up from the September Planning Board meeting, when last SOLO HS presented.
Several items have been added to the Public file since the last meeting. Here are the most important. Each item links to a copy of the file on our local site and our Google Drive backup
- Minutes from the Saugerties Planning Board October 20 2026 Meeting (Oct 21 2026) Local link /// Google Drive link
- Minutes from the Saugerties Planning Board September 15 2026 Meeting (Sept 16 2026) Local link /// Google Drive link
- Comments from the Town Consultants NPV about the FEAF Part 2 (October 16 2026) Local Link /// Google Drive link
- Town Engineers B&L initial engineering review (October 19 2026) http://southpeaknabe.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/2026-10-19-BL-Town-Engineers-Review.pdf Local Link /// Google Drive link
- SOLO HS FEAF Expanded Narrative (November 4 2026) Local link /// Google Drive link
We are NOT in receipt of the FEAF Part 2 mentioned at the October meeting. 2026 nov 16 EDIT: We are now in receipt of the FEAF Part 2 (October 7 2026?) Local link /// Google Drive link
2026-11-04-SOLO-FEAF-Expanded-Environmental-Assessment-Form-Narrative
We would characterize the November 4, 2026 Expanded EAF Narrative above as an advocacy document pleading for a Negative Declaration, not as a document demonstrating that the outstanding technical and environmental issues have actually been resolved. There are still too many outstanding issues for the Board to offer a Neg Dec, not even a Neg Dec with conditions. There is a lot of hand-waving “We’ll get to that later”
Matters outstanding
Still materially unresolved
• Potential contamination of proposed residential wells
• NYS DOH requirements/policies concerning those wells
• Final SWPPP
• WQv/RRv calculations (also identified by B&L Engineers)
• Exact LOD/disturbance area
• Full steep-slope/grading analysis
• Full road profile
• 2,200-foot private road vs. Town requirements
• Existing wells
• Principal-aquifer/septic groundwater-quality analysis
• Species-specific habitat analysis
• Legally enforceable conservation/mitigation instruments
Partially addressed
• Bedrock
• Construction duration
• Groundwater quantity
• Septic systems
• Wildlife/habitat
• Open-space preservation
• Wetland mitigation enforceability
• Road impacts
• Historic/archaeological concerns
• Stormwater concepts
So, a letter to the Board will include a summary of questions about the current situation and will emphasize that the Board should continue careful scrutiny and not offer a Negative Declaration for SEQR purposes.
The Board should:
1. Receive and review the revised site plan and SWPPP;
2. Obtain the Town Engineer’s subsequent review and response;
3. Quantify the actual disturbance to 15%-and-greater slopes;
4. Establish one definitive limits-of-disturbance figure;
5. Require a complete response concerning groundwater quality, PFAS, 1,4-dioxane, the proposed wells and neighboring wells;
6. Clarify the legal basis for the approximately 2,200-foot private rural road;
7. Establish permanent legal protection for the proposed conservation/greenbelt lands; and
8. Only then determine whether the completed record supports a Negative Declaration.
Earlier Items
Relevant passage from the DRAFT October Meeting minutes
3. Major Subdivision (9-Lot), Solo Holidays, LLC, Cottontail Lane / Route 212. Presented by Khattar Elmassalemah, Praetorius & Conrad, P.C. Elmassalemah-the applicant has requested that the open public hearing be adjourned until the November 17, 2026 monthly meeting and wanted to attend this meeting to see what needs to be completed in hopes that SEQR can be completed and the public hearing can be closed next month.
The draft EAF Part II was received (Note: SouthPeakNabe has not received this item from the Public File) and concerned with the items that are marked moderate to large impact. The impact on land where the proposed construction will impact land with a slope of 15% or greater is where the road makes a bend. Regarding impact on plants and animals the applicant has proposed green belts to preserve habitat of wildlife. There is a lot of forested area that will remain. Impacts on groundwater, the applicant is proposing a use of 2.7 gallons per minute over the nine proposed wells and the perk test demonstrates that there is 16 gallons per minute available. We are proposing a minimum impact on archeological and historic resources, SHPO letter from 2022 indicating that there was no impact for the Terramor project which was significantly larger that what we are proposing. Traffic Impact-we plan on constructing the roadway, 5 acres at a time, based on buyers. Requiring approximately a 24-month construction period because we do not know how long it will take, will be based on sales. Mitigation area to be built first with the entrance and roadwork. Maintenance can be added to the legal documents. Stormwater is being discussed with the Town Engineer.
Beltrani- we require a Part III response to determine if a negative declaration is appropriate. We can not close the public hearing until SEQR is completed. Impacts on land with slopes of 15% or greater are moderate to large when you take into consideration area of slope disturbance, it must be quantified. Cut and fill that area. If the Board feels it should be changed to little to no impact it can be updated on the EAF Part III but that is up to the Board.
Hlavaty- impacts relative to the area of the steep slopes.
Elmassalemah- regarding the bedrock concerns, there will be no hammering of bedrock. Some of the homes maynot be able to have basements but that will be addressed per parcel.
Beltrani- the Board has received several EAF Part I documents and the limits of disturbance have changed several times. We defer to the Town Engineer for review. The purpose of Part II is to look at the documentation that is before the Board at the time of consideration. We will need a Part III response before we can move forward with SEQR.
Elmassalemah- Woodstock Day School is not within 1,500’ of the project location. The dump is located further than indicated.
Beltrani- we will update to reflect that. Elmassalemah-we will work on Part III for the next meeting and re-open the public hearing as planned.
No further action can be taken by the Board at this time.
You can see a summary of the September session in the Saugerties Planning Board Minutes on the Board’s website here:
https://saugertiesny.gov/application/files/1517/9259/8636/September_15_2026_-_Meeting_Minutes.pdf
You can also see our archived version of the Minutes here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1q2zdCJ-ehbcMsgL97pj1PlD_k_JqWupJ/view?usp=sharing
Here is the relevant text:
2. Major Subdivision (9-Lot), Solo Holidays, LLC, Cottontail Lane / Route 212. Presented by Khattar Elmassalemah, Praetorius & Conrad, P.C. The applicant is back to re-open a previously adjourned public hearing in hopes that the project can move forward. The proposed 9-lotsubdivision on the 77 acre parcel has not significantly changed since the board last reviewed it. The building envelope on Lot #2 was moved internally further to address comments made at the last public hearing. The Army Corps of Engineers has accepted the mitigation of the wetlands as proposed. Started the process with the Ulster County Health Department. SWPPP was submitted to the Town Engineer for review. We have received the NPV review memo. Submitted the updated FEAF as requested. NYSDOT has given the green light to submit the application. Was awaiting the USACE response for mitigation before beginning that process. We have received the comment letter from the adjacent neighbor, Mr. Pisani, and prepared a response memo.
Post re-opened the public hearing at 7:40pm.
Public Comments:
● Mark Pisani, 11 Osnas Lane-a copy of the response memo from Praetorius & Conrad, P.C. was given to Mr. Pisani. Pisani- comment has been addressed that there is no existing stormwater management pond currently on site. So no request for waiver is needed. The calculation comment remains relevant.
Elmassalemah- 61 acres of the site already has natural drainage and is not being rerouted.
Pisani- typo comments are being addressed and there is a templating issue that is being addressed. Is the infiltration not included?
Elmassalemah- not infiltrating into the ground. The SWPPP is not using infiltration. The storage area is included with the stormwater ponds. Needs to be reviewed by the Town Engineer and they will review all the calculations to ensure accuracy. IF there are errors they will be addressed at that time. We have included the Town Engineer in our response to your comment letter so they are aware of your concerns.
Pisani- when will the perk (sic) test be performed?
Elmasselmah- awating UCHD to witness the perk tests, as required.
Pisani- it looks like there are two wet ponds and two dry ponds proposed, correct?
Elmassalemah- correct, the dry pond will help to slow down flow.● Cory Smith, 49 Raybrook Drive- do not approve of this project because of the dangers that are present from its proximity to the Super Fund site. It is located directly across Route 212. There is currently dioxane in the water across Route 212 and the people that live there have to use bottled water. Six of the last ten years have been drought conditions. The addition of 9 wells will create a serious issue. The fractured bedrock underneath does not allow for a clear understanding of how the run off flows. The parcels are considered an area of interest for NYSDEC regarding dioxane and PFOS. NYSDEC has not put out the latest report regarding where the “bloom” is and where the chemicals can seep into. John Joy Road and Artist Way residents are also on bottled water. The Town pays for their water. There are potentially contaminated areas. Adding additional wells will increase the probability of contamination further. Urge the board to wait until NYSDEC comes out with their new report before making any
decision. There is no way to sink 9 new deep wells and ensure neighbors have clean and safe drinking water.Elmassalemah- we are requesting the Board to close the public hearing at this time. We have given the public
ample time to ask questions and voice their concerns.
Beltrani- the Board is not ready to move forward with SEQR at this time and procedurally can not close the public hearing until they can. They will have to leave it open until SEQR can be determined. Once closed the Board will run the risk of automatic approvals. We can adjourn until a later date if that is what the applicant wants, you can provide updates to the Board in the meantime without having to be on the agenda as a public hearing. This is an ecologically sensitive site and there are outstanding planning comments that have not been addressed. The UCPB had concerns regarding the conservation areas that are left out of the green belt. Wetlands would be protected under the greenbelt. The Building envelopes establish the limit of disturbance. If someone that purchases the lot and wants to move the building envelope it would require a site plan review. This is a Type I Action under SEQR and the Board has not completed their review as such. Need comments from the Town Engineer regarding grading. What does the
USACE mitigation look like and who oversees that. NPV does have a wetland scientist on staff. Mitigation
performed as provided.
Elmassalemah- the project has already been submitted to the USACE and they have accepted the scope of work to be performed. Why do we need another professional to review it?
Beltrani- The approval to move forward was based on lapse in response in the required timeframe and further review may be beneficial.
Kiniry- is it customary for our Board to require a review of the USACE determination?
Furman- has the USACE been on site?
Elmassalemah- not sure if they have been on site, but the plans have been submitted and we have received a response from them.
Post- if the Board does decide to have the wetland scientist review the project it will be at no additional cost to the applicant.
The Board agreed that if the review is of no cost to the applicant and does not hold up the review process it should be done by the wetland specialist at NPV.
Elmassalemah- green belt is demonstrated heavily to the west between development. What are the concerns regarding the location of the green belts proposed?
Beltrani-the suggestion in our memo is to follow some of the wetlands and steep slopes and incorporate them into the green belt areas to preserve them, for ecological benefit. There was plume research done with the previous Terramor project that can be utilized for this project. The applicant should get a copy of that research and demonstrate how it is related to their project. There is still some significant review before the board can come to a SEQR determination. The applicant can request the public hearing be adjourned again if they wish to give themselves some time to submit additional information that will help the Planning Board come to a SEQR determination. The applicant can always come to meetings in the interim to discuss the project further in hopes of moving in that direction. Once SEQR is closer to a determination the applicant can request to open the public hearing again.
Elmassalemah- we would like to adjourn the public hearing until the November monthly meeting but attend the October meeting to discuss the progress of the project.A motion was made by Hlavaty, seconded by Kiniry, to adjourn the public hearing until the November 17, 2026
monthly meeting. Board vote: Post-Aye, Furman-Aye, Tiano-Recuse, Hlavaty-Aye, Kiniry-Aye. Motion
carried.
Here are more documents submitted to the public file since our last update, which was before the September meeting.
2026-09-02-ACOE-USACE-Response-about-proposed-wetland-mitigation (Army Corps of Engineers says that they have not commented in 45 days and so SOLO can go ahead with work)
2026-09-14-Pisani-letter-to-Saugerties-Planning-Board-about-SOLO-SWPPP This letter to the Board is basically a reprise of the notes made in the last post here.
2026-09-15-PandC-Response-to-Pisani-concerns-about-Draft-SWPPP Response from applicants’ engineers to the issues raised in the letter above.
2026-09-14-Saugerties-Highway-Dept-No-Jurisdiction-Letter Saugerties Highway Department has no issues with current plans as long as other regulations are followed.
2026-09-15-FEAF-Part-1 Full Environmental Assessment Form Part 1
Our apologies for not getting to explain or analyze in detail here.
The SOLO HS project is the first item on the agenda for the Public Hearing portion of the Saugerties Town Planning Board Meeting of Tuesday November 17th – The meeting will take place at 7:30 at the Saugerties Senior Center – NOTE: The room will likely be very very crowded, as the second item on the Public Hearing agenda is the KCE Battery proposal
Finally, please note that many (if not all) items from the Public File are available in a shared folder at https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1W41ykw_tlGHlCXSpNOwzdlS6h27dfnPO?usp=drive_link
They are named sequentially with the date of the document at the start of the name. This allows you to view them in the order in which they arrived in the Public File.

